Navigating Today's Investment Market

Frank DiLeo, GBU Life Investment Portfolio Manager • April 4, 2023

Why consistent interest rates may yield the best long-term result.

Investing in fixed annuities has historically required minimal research or projections from our members. Here at GBU, we always stand steadfast in our beliefs that a strong, conservative portfolio of high quality assets will serve our members well in attaining consistent returns to help meet their investment needs. With the luxury of time, and the benefit of compounding interest, we have been able to serve our members for over 130 years, with one of the finest reputations of any fraternal benefit society. However, with current market conditions and trends, we are noticing a new phenomenon in investing,  and we at GBU think it is important to consider it when evaluating your current and future investments.


GBU's annuity and insurance products consist mainly of two components, time and rate. In our fixed rate, Asset Guard Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) products, which GBU began to offer in 2021, each contract consists of a fixed rate and a duration/surrender period, after which the contract can terminate or continue. The member can then reinvest their principal in either a new product or remain with a GBU MYGA at the new renewal rate.


The risks involved in fixed income investing, while minimal, do affect our members, and we do our best to educate them when we feel it is necessary. A risk we believe is being disregarded is “reinvestment risk.” Today, it seems you can’t drive by a local bank without seeing signs for 5% One-Year promotional CD rates. We want our members to understand the potential costs and pitfalls of being lured by such investments.


As the Federal Reserve (Fed) has raised rates in an attempt to slow the economy, the Fed Funds rate, the rate at which banks borrow money, is expected to approach 5%. Should the Fed’s goal be reached, the US economy will “cool off,” bringing down inflation, and giving the economy a more realistic base to continue its steady path of growth. But what happens when we do reach that goal? Well, investors believe the market will then require a “shot in the arm” to stimulate growth and investing back into the economy. In order to do that, the Fed will likely begin to lower those very rates it raised, and we will see rates once the risks involved in fixed income investing, while minimal, do affect our members, and we do our best to educate them when we feel it is necessary. A risk we believe is being disregarded is “reinvestment risk.” Today, it seems you can’t drive by a local bank without seeing signs for 5% One-Year promotional CD rates. We want our members to understand the potential costs and pitfalls of being lured by such investments.


The bedrock of financial investment has always rested on time. Banks and investment institutions are offered an ability to lend money in the short term while investing in the longer term. In a healthy interest rate environment, longer term yields are expected to be, and almost always are higher than what you can expect to receive for shorter investments. The age-old principal of “time value of money" states, the longer I invest my money, the more I should receive in return for my commitment. But what happens in the rare instance when that is not the case? Imagine a friend asked to borrow $10 and offered to pay you back $11 in a week, or $9 in two weeks, surely anyone would insist on payment in a week. There are instances where time can be your enemy in investing, and we want our members to be aware when investing for their future.


As the Federal Reserve (Fed) has raised rates  in an attempt to slow the economy, the Fed  Funds rate, the rate at which banks borrow  money, is expected to approach 5%. Should  the Fed’s goal be reached, the US economy will  “cool off,” bringing down inflation, and giving  the economy a more realistic base to continue  its steady path of growth. But what happens  when we do reach that goal? Well, investors  believe the market will then require a “shot in  the arm” to stimulate growth and investing  back into the economy. In order to do that, the  Fed will likely begin to lower those very rates it raised, and we will see rates once again trend lower, as they have been for the better part of 30-40 years. So why bother raising rates at all, only to bring them back down? And what should you consider as an investor?


Historically investors would simply invest in the highest yields, for the shortest duration. When that contract was to expire, simply do the same process over, “wash-rinse-repeat.” The issue becomes, what if the rate you receive after that investment matures is lower? Are you willing to reinvest that 5% One- Year rate at 3% when that contract is up, then at 2% when that contract is up? That is why it is important to understand that sometimes you can make time work for you. By locking in rates now, you take out much of the  “reinvesting” risk in the future. Taking a similar rate for longer now, may be the prudent choice if your timeline allows it. While many love a “teaser” rate, we at GBU want our members to be educated as to why companies offer them, and the pitfalls that may come with them, especially in a market where rates are expected to eventually come down significantly.


At GBU, our primary objective is supporting the needs of our members. Your timeline may not be affected by the markets, and we stress the goal is always to do what is best for you and your family. If you have any questions about any of our annuity products, or markets in general, we are always here to discuss a plan that fits your needs.


This chart shows the yield curve from January 2017, which is a typical yield curve. Rates are low on the front end, trend up and then level off.

This chart shows the current yield curve. Here, the front-end rates are higher than longer rates and the intermediate rates (belly of the curve) are lower than longer rates (back end). The expectation is that the Fed will start lowering rates in 6 months, resulting in a precipitous drop in yields. Reinvesting money in that June 2023 and later window will likely mean lower rates on your reinvestment. 


GBU Life is the marketing name for GBU Financial Life. Annuities are not short-term products and are issued by GBU Financial Life (GBU), Pittsburgh, PA. Products and features may vary by state. Withdrawals prior to 59½ may be subject to IRS penalties. This is a summary of the contract provisions. Please refer to the contract for details of surrender charge schedule, benefits and exclusions. No statement contained herein shall constitute tax, legal or investment advice. You should consult with a legal or tax professional for any such matters. NOT A DEPOSIT OF A BANK-MAY LOSE VALUE-NOT BANK GUARANTEED. Contract Form Series:

ICC22_FPDA_CON_(01-22), FPDA_CON_(01-22)_FL, FPDA_CON_(01-22), ICC21_SPDA_CON_(4-21),

SPDA_CON_(4-21)_FL, SPDA_CON_(4-21). 

November 20, 2024
Winter is a perfect time to bond with family and create cozy, memorable moments. From fun games to creative crafts, here are some top indoor activities to bring everyone together.
November 13, 2024
Since its launch in 2014, the Welcome Home program by Operation Troop Appreciation has become a beacon of support for veteran families, impacting thousands who’ve bravely served but now face the challenges of civilian life. The program fills a crucial gap by helping prevent homelessness and poverty among veterans and providing much-needed assistance as they establish new lives.
November 7, 2024
In honor of Veterans Day, GBU compiled a blog featuring those who have served our country. GBU members were invited to share stories of the veterans in their lives, helping to honor their service and sacrifices and ensuring their legacy is remembered and celebrated.
November 4, 2024
In a world filled with busy schedules, digital distractions and seemingly endless goals, it can be easy to forget to pause and appreciate what we already have. Here are some practical ways to bring thankfulness into your daily routine.
November 1, 2024
Winter is a magical time filled with holidays and the warmth of togetherness. It’s the perfect season to start traditions that your kids will look forward to every year. Here are some creative ideas to start your family’s unique winter traditions!
October 29, 2024
As winter rolls in and the days grow shorter, it’s the perfect time to shift focus indoors and tackle some projects. Here are five effective strategies to organize your home this winter.
October 28, 2024
These practical steps will help you stay cozy and save on energy bills all season long.
Two people hugging
October 16, 2024
Wondering how your donation to The GBU Foundation fuels opportunities and growth in communities? Here you'll find stories from some of the the 2024 Community Grant Award winners.
Person sitting on floor packing luggage
October 15, 2024
Here are a few handy tips to keep in your back pocket while traveling for Thanksgiving.
Backpacker outside on a hike
October 14, 2024
Four fall activities that can also serve as a workout.
More Posts
Share by: